AI Law - International Review of Artificial Intelligence Law
G. Giappichelli Editore

16/10/2024 - Testing AI in Law: How Generative AI Struggled with Legal Exam Questions (USA)

argument: Notizie/News - Legal Technology

Source: The Conversation

This article details an experiment where generative AI was tasked with attempting an undergraduate law exam. While the AI performed well on simpler, fact-based questions, it struggled significantly with more complex legal problems that required deep analysis, critical thinking, and nuanced interpretation of legal principles.

The experiment highlights the limitations of generative AI in the field of legal education, particularly when it comes to solving intricate legal scenarios that demand an understanding of context, precedent, and the application of abstract legal theories.

Although AI can assist with tasks like legal research and document drafting, the article emphasizes that current AI models are not yet capable of replacing human judgment in the legal field. The AI’s weaknesses in handling complex legal questions suggest that while it can be a helpful tool for legal professionals, it lacks the depth required to fully engage with the complexities of law.

The article concludes that while AI may play an increasingly important role in legal education and practice, it is unlikely to replace human lawyers anytime soon, especially in areas requiring deep legal reasoning and judgment.