AI Law - International Review of Artificial Intelligence LawCC BY-NC-SA Commercial Licence
G. Giappichelli Editore

15/02/2025 - Can AI-Created Works Be Copyrighted? Legal Debate Heats Up (USA)

argument: Notizie/News - Intellectual Property Law

Source: Laredo Morning Times

The Laredo Morning Times article discusses recent legal debates on whether AI-assisted works can receive copyright protection. The U.S. Copyright Office has clarified that for an AI-generated work to be eligible for copyright, it must include a sufficient level of human creative input.

The main legal issue is defining how much human involvement is required for AI-generated content to qualify for protection. While purely AI-created works are not copyrightable, those where a human has significantly edited or directed the AI’s output may be eligible. This standard is being tested in recent cases where artists and writers are incorporating AI into their creative processes.

The article highlights a growing trend of AI-assisted creativity, from AI-generated paintings to machine-learning-driven music compositions. However, legal experts warn that without clear guidelines, AI copyright disputes could become more frequent.

Another concern is the impact of AI-generated works on traditional copyright holders. If AI can create content similar to human-made works, questions arise about originality, fair use, and market competition. Some argue that AI’s ability to replicate artistic styles could lead to legal challenges over derivative works and unauthorized imitation.

The discussion concludes with insights into potential future legal reforms. Policymakers and copyright offices worldwide are exploring new frameworks to balance AI innovation with the protection of human creativity, ensuring that AI does not undermine existing copyright laws.