AI Law - International Review of Artificial Intelligence LawCC BY-NC-SA Commercial Licence
G. Giappichelli Editore

05/03/2025 - Courts Challenge AI’s Fair Use Defense in Copyright Lawsuits (USA)

argument: Notizie/News - Intellectual Property Law

Source: Nquiringminds

Nquiringminds reports on a series of recent U.S. court rulings that have cast doubt on the applicability of the fair use defense in AI copyright infringement cases. These decisions challenge AI developers’ claims that using copyrighted material for training machine learning models falls under fair use protections.

Courts have increasingly scrutinized whether AI training is “transformative” enough to qualify for fair use, particularly when the resulting models are used for commercial purposes. Judges have also raised concerns about the potential market harm to original content creators when their work is used without permission.

Legal experts argue that these rulings could set significant precedents, leading to more stringent copyright enforcement in AI development. The decisions also highlight the need for clearer legal frameworks to address the complex intersection between AI, data usage, and intellectual property rights.